Javascript Question posted in
A very good W3school tutorial can be found here.

Javascript – Unable to understand the difference between normal comparison of strings and comparison using localCompare() method as both works differently

`I am a newbie in JavaScript and to programming. Need assistance to clarify this doubt

console.log('a'>'A'); This code returns True

let result = 'a'.localeCompare('A'); 
console.log(result); 
console.log(Intl.DateTimeFormat().resolvedOptions().locale);

This code returns -1 and my locale is en-IN

This is creating a confusion because, if ‘a’>’A’ then localeCompare() should return 1 instead it is returning -1

Checked for the working of localeCompare() method and it runs on some Unicode collation algorithm so unable to follow up with it.`

Tags:

3

Answers


  1. 0

    The order of different cases the same letter in localeCompare depends on the locale, so you can’t rely on it being the same as 'a'>'A' everywhere.

    If you want to ensure the order of these are consistent, regardless of locale, you can use the caseFirst setting.
    For example:

    'a'.localeCompare('A', 'en-IN', {caseFirst:'upper'});

    will return a positive number, which sounds like it’s what your expecting.

    Alternatively, you can use the sensitivity setting if you’d like to ignore case altogether

    'a'.localeCompare('A', 'en-IN', {sensitivity:'base'});

    will return a zero.

    Login or Signup to reply.
  2. 0

    In JavaScript, string comparison can behave differently depending on the method used. Let’s break down the behavior of the two examples you’ve provided:

    Direct String Comparison (‘a’ > ‘A’):
    When you use the greater-than operator (>), JavaScript performs a comparison based on the Unicode values of the characters.
    In Unicode, the lowercase ‘a’ has a higher value (97) than the uppercase ‘A’ (65), so ‘a’ > ‘A’ evaluates to true.

    localeCompare() Method:
    The localeCompare() method compares two strings in the current locale and returns a number indicating whether the reference string comes before, after, or is the same as the given string in sort order.
    The return values are:
    -1 if the reference string (‘a’) comes before the comparison string (‘A’).
    1 if the reference string (‘a’) comes after the comparison string (‘A’).
    0 if the two strings are equivalent.
    localeCompare() uses locale-specific rules to determine the sort order. In many locales, including ‘en-IN’ (Indian English), the lowercase letters are considered to come after uppercase letters in alphabetical order, so ‘a’.localeCompare(‘A’) returns -1.

    Direct Comparison (‘a’ > ‘A’):
    This is a direct Unicode value comparison without considering locale-specific rules, and it relies purely on the character codes.
    localeCompare() Method:

    This considers the collation rules of the specified or default locale, which often place uppercase letters before lowercase letters, reflecting common dictionary order.

    The observed behavior is consistent with how these two different comparison methods work:
    Direct comparison (‘a’ > ‘A’) checks character codes directly.
    localeCompare() considers locale-specific sorting rules, which can place uppercase letters before lowercase ones.

    The confusion arises from the different purposes and implementations of these two methods. Direct comparison is simple and straightforward, while localeCompare() is more complex and takes into account cultural sorting norms.

    Login or Signup to reply.
  3. 0

    Your confusion arises from the different ways JavaScript handles string comparisons with > and the localeCompare method.

    String Comparison with > Operator
    When you use the > operator to compare strings in JavaScript:

    console.log('a' > 'A');  // true

    This comparison is based on the Unicode values of the characters. In Unicode, lowercase letters have higher values than uppercase letters. The Unicode value for ‘a’ (U+0061) is greater than the value for ‘A’ (U+0041), so ‘a’ > ‘A’ evaluates to true.

    String Comparison with localeCompare Method
    The localeCompare method compares two strings according to the sort order of the specified locale. By default, it uses the locale and collation rules that are set in your environment, which can lead to different results than direct Unicode comparison:

    let result = 'a'.localeCompare('A');
console.log(result);  // -1
console.log(Intl.DateTimeFormat().resolvedOptions().locale);  // en-IN

enter code here
    Login or Signup to reply.
Please signup or login to give your own answer.

Back To Top
Search