Question 115195 in Mongodb Question posted in
The official documentation can be found here.

Mongodb – How does mongo replica set elections behave when some nodes are dead?

Let’s say I have 5 nodes replica set.

3 of them are dead, 2 alive.

How would the majority will be calculated? 5 nodes majority would be 5/2+1=3 but if 3 nodes are dead, will it still look for 3 votes? There are only 2 alive so only 2 votes… or the majority will be 2/2+1=2 which is still confusing because what will happen at the elections, and does read/write concerns has any affect to any of these…

Basically the number n in n/2+1 to from majority indicates the whole replica set memebers length (of members that can vote dead or alive) or the length of only alive nodes?

I tried manually killing 3 nodes in a 5 node replica set (4 plus arbiter, killed also the arbiter) and the 2 left nodes both became secondaries and I couldn’t reach the db.

And I tried the same thing in a 3 nodes replica set (without an arbiter) and killed 1 node, so it’s the same as the first test where only 2 data nodes are alive and it did elect a primary and the Db worked.

I’m trying to understand what’s difference between both of them.

Tags:

2

Answers


  1. 0

    When your replica set has 5 members (i.e. 5 voting members) then the majority is 3 which means at least 3 nodes have to up and reachable in order to elect a PRIMARY. Otherwise the nodes remains in SECONDARY state.

    Have a look at MongoClient to connect to multiple hosts to handle failover?

    Login or Signup to reply.
  2. 0

    Assuming you dont change priority, hidden or votes in the nodes configuration (e.g. you use default replicaSet settings ) and you dont have ARBITER , here is what happen:

    1) How many members replicaSet allow to be down at same time?

    3x members replicaSet allow only 1 from 3 members to be down at same time and replicaSet will be still writable ( e.g. PRIMARY will be elected )

    5x members replicaSet allow only 2 from 5 members to be down at same time and replicaSet will be still writable ( e.g. PRIMARY will be elected )

    7x members replicaSet allow only 3 from 7 members to be down at same time and replicaSet will be still writable ( e.g. PRIMARY will be elected )

    2) What happen if more members are down than allowed?

    If in 3x members replicaSet there is 2x members down , election will be triggered and the member that is still alive will not receive majority of members votes , so if it was PRIMARY will switch to SECONDARY , if it was SECONDARY it will stay SECONDARY. ReplicaSet will be still readable but writes will be not possible , the same happen with any other replicaSet when less them majority of members are available.

    Login or Signup to reply.
Please signup or login to give your own answer.

Back To Top
Search