skip to Main Content

I’m inserting hundreds of thousands of objects using NSBatchInsert, now i want to add relationships between objects (let say A and B, with 1-to-many relationship) as no batch operation supports relationship i will need to use the most efficient and fast way to achieve what I want, the best way I could think of is to use "GroupBy" to fetch object, but this will lead to start a loop to fetch the A entity (as the Key of the Dictionary will be a property not an object).

is there any way to have a Dictionary as fetch result having as Key an NSManagedObject (the A object) and the value an Array of NSManagedObject (B objects) ?

-> let result: [A: [B]]

Thank you

2

Answers


  1. To achieve this, you can’t directly group by NSManagedObject itself, as CoreData doesn’t allow grouping by object references in fetch results. However, you can perform a fetch to get the related objects (B) and then use a dictionary to manually group them by their related A objects.

    Here’s an approach:

    Perform a fetch for the B objects along with their related A objects using a NSFetchRequest with a NSPredicate or a NSBatchInsertRequest for efficiency.
    After fetching, iterate through the B objects and group them by their A object’s unique identifier (for comparison).
    swift
    Copy code

     let fetchRequest: NSFetchRequest<B> = B.fetchRequest()
     fetchRequest.relationshipKeyPathsForPrefetching = ["a"] // Ensure A is 
      fetched
     do {
       let bObjects = try context.fetch(fetchRequest)
       var groupedResult: [A: [B]] = [:]
    
       for b in bObjects {
         if let a = b.a {
            groupedResult[a, default: []].append(b)
         }
     }
    } catch {
    print("Failed to fetch B objects: (error)")
    }
    

    Optimizing Performance

    1. Use NSFetchedResultsController (optional)
      If you’re displaying the results in a UI (e.g., in a table view), you can use NSFetchedResultsController for even better memory management and efficient change tracking. It’s designed for large datasets and efficiently manages fetches and memory.

    2. Avoid Using Dictionary for Grouping Large Datasets
      If the dataset is extremely large, you might run into memory issues when trying to keep a large dictionary in memory. In such cases, consider writing to a persistent store (like a temporary cache file) or an in-memory database (e.g., SQLite) to keep track of groupings while limiting memory usage.

    3. Parallelize Fetching (Optional)
      If you’re working with a large number of A objects and the fetching of B objects is independent for each A, you might benefit from fetching in parallel using DispatchQueue or OperationQueue. Just be mindful of thread safety when working with Core Data.

    Example of Parallel Fetching

    let dispatchGroup = DispatchGroup()
    
    for a in aObjects {
       dispatchGroup.enter()
    
    DispatchQueue.global(qos: .userInitiated).async {
        let fetchRequestB: NSFetchRequest<B> = B.fetchRequest()
        fetchRequestB.predicate = NSPredicate(format: "a == %@", a)
        fetchRequestB.fetchBatchSize = 1000
        
        do {
            let bObjects = try context.fetch(fetchRequestB)
            synchronized(groupedResult) {
                groupedResult[a] = bObjects
            }
        } catch {
            print("Error fetching B objects for A: (error)")
        }
    
        dispatchGroup.leave()
    }
    }
    
    dispatchGroup.wait() // Wait for all batches to finish
    

    Here, synchronized is a custom function that ensures safe access to the shared dictionary groupedResult across multiple threads.

    Final Thoughts

    Memory Usage: Be cautious of memory usage when grouping large datasets. You can optimize further by breaking large fetch requests into smaller pieces and processing data incrementally.

    Batching: Use fetchBatchSize to control how much data is loaded into memory at once.

    Threading: For very large datasets, parallelizing fetch operations can improve performance, but make sure to handle Core Data context and thread safety properly.

    Optimization: If performance is still an issue, consider processing the data in background threads and writing intermediate results to disk rather than keeping everything in memory at once.

    By batching your fetch requests and using an efficient method for lazy loading and grouping, you should be able to handle the large datasets without running into memory issues.

    Login or Signup to reply.
  2. A dictionary of [A: [B]] efficiently, where A is an NSManagedObject representing the parent entity and [B] is an array of related objects, you’ll need a solution that minimizes looping and fetches while working with Core Data.

    Approach 1: Fetch A Entities and Use NSManagedObject Relationships

    // Assume we have a managed object context `context`
    let fetchRequest: NSFetchRequest<A> = A.fetchRequest()
    
    do {
        let aObjects = try context.fetch(fetchRequest)
        var result: [A: [B]] = [:]
        
        for a in aObjects {
            if let bObjects = a.bRelation?.allObjects as? [B] {
                result[a] = bObjects
            }
        }
        // Now `result` contains the grouped dictionary
    } catch {
        print("Failed to fetch A entities: (error)")
    }
    

    Core Data automatically manages the relationship, so accessing a.bRelation fetches related objects lazily (or eagerly if configured with a Fetch Request for preloading)

    Approach 2: Use a Fetch Request with NSDictionaryResultType

    let fetchRequest = NSFetchRequest<NSDictionary>(entityName: "B")
    fetchRequest.resultType = .dictionaryResultType
    
    // Assuming "aProperty" is the property that links B to A
    fetchRequest.propertiesToFetch = ["aProperty"]
    fetchRequest.propertiesToGroupBy = ["aProperty"]
    
    do {
        let groupedResults = try context.fetch(fetchRequest)
        var result: [A: [B]] = [:]
    
        for group in groupedResults {
            if let aObject = group["aProperty"] as? A {
                let bFetchRequest: NSFetchRequest<B> = B.fetchRequest()
                bFetchRequest.predicate = NSPredicate(format: "aProperty == %@", aObject)
                
                let bObjects = try context.fetch(bFetchRequest)
                result[aObject] = bObjects
            }
        }
        // `result` now contains the grouped dictionary
    } catch {
        print("Failed to group and fetch: (error)")
    }
    

    NSDictionaryResultType allows you to group objects in the database query itself, reducing the in-memory operation overhead.

    Approach 3: Batch Fetch and Process Relationships

    let batchSize = 500
    
    // Fetch all B objects in batches
    let fetchRequest: NSFetchRequest<B> = B.fetchRequest()
    fetchRequest.fetchBatchSize = batchSize
    
    do {
        let bObjects = try context.fetch(fetchRequest)
        var result: [A: [B]] = [:]
        
        for b in bObjects {
            if let a = b.aRelation { // Assuming `aRelation` is the to-one relationship to A
                if result[a] == nil {
                    result[a] = []
                }
                result[a]?.append(b)
            }
        }
        // `result` now contains the grouped dictionary
    } catch {
        print("Failed to fetch B entities: (error)")
    }
    
    Login or Signup to reply.
Please signup or login to give your own answer.
Back To Top
Search